You'd never guess — not in a million years — all of the famous names on this list of Rosario's rumored boyfriends.
Jay-Z, 2000
The two supposedly dated in 2000 — and people assumed that the second verse in Jay's song "Lost Ones" was about her ...until he went on record to say it was actually about Beyoncé years later.
Source: oldloves.tumblr.com / via: madamenoire.com
Joshua Jackson, 2002-2003
She once said of their breakup, "[Josh]would get all these calls because supposedly before we broke up, we had already broken up in the trades, in the rags or whatever."
Source: oldloves.tumblr.com
Colin Farrell, 2004
The pair were linked — and seen looking more than chummy — on the set of Alexander.
Source: Mark Sullivan / WireImage
Jason Lewis, 2004-2006
The pair lived together in Los Angeles for a few years but never got engaged (as some outlets reported).
Image by Peter Kramer / Getty Images